Own a Piece of Hingham History | 261 Gardner Street

Set along Hingham’s historic Gardner Street corridor, 261 Gardner Street is a rare reminder of the town’s farming past. Known as the Hosea Whiting (Whiton) House, this antique farmstead was once home to one of Hingham’s most prominent families. The Whitons trace their roots back to the 1640s — just a generation after the Pilgrims — and for centuries played a defining role in Liberty Plain as farmers, constables, and community leaders. When Hosea Whiton (1782–1869) married Anna Stodder in 1804, this farmstead became their household and a lasting part of Hingham’s story.

Like many New England antiques, the home carries a bit of mystery. Public records date the property to 1740, while the town’s historic inventory places it closer to 1804. The truth is likely both. Early homes were often rebuilt and expanded by each generation, reusing timbers or foundations from the original structure. These layers create discrepancies in the records, but they also add to the intrigue, making 261 Gardner Street a true opportunity to own a piece of Hingham’s history.

A Private Compound with Endless Potential

Today, the property lives like a private compound, blending historic character with versatile spaces. The estate includes:

The Main Residence — Brimming with old-world charm, the two-bedroom, two-bath home retains its historic details with wide plank floors, exposed beams, and a remarkable hearth that once served as the original kitchen. Gas fireplaces warm both the large living room and dining room, while the eat-in kitchen features a full pantry. A bonus room, filled with natural light, offers flexibility — easily converted into a first-floor primary ensuite.
The Stand-Alone Cottage — Complete with plumbing for a full bathroom, this cottage is ready to be finished as a guest house, in-law suite, or studio.
The Unfinished Barn — Equipped with electricity, the barn offers untapped potential to be reimagined into a home office, workshop, or bonus entertaining space.

All of this is framed by mature landscaping that creates a secluded, almost whimsical retreat — a setting that feels worlds away, yet remains conveniently close to Route 3 and Derby Plaza.

A Unique Offering

More than a home, 261 Gardner Street is a living piece of Hingham’s history. It blends heritage, charm, and convenience in one timeless setting — an opportunity rarely found at this price point. For those seeking a residence that offers character, privacy, and potential, this antique estate stands as a one-of-a-kind offering.